This week in The Red Report

  1. The long shadow of Jensen Huang

  2. What now for US tech policy? 

  3. Nvidia scandal reveals fault lines in US AI sector

  4. Can US tech companies maintain their edge against China?

  5. Huang is the headline; foreign commercial espionage is far, far more widespread

For those who wish a more in depth discussion of Red Report analyses, please sign up for Red Report Live, a one-hour discussion with the authors. Each session is one hour and costs $250 per attendance or $2,500 for an annual subscription to 12 sessions. To sign up, please email [email protected].

From Zhongnanhai: This week in Chinese Politics

The long shadow of Jensen Huang

China denies involvement with Jensen Huang’s affair. Denial will do little to stem the fallout for US-China relations, regardless of President Trump’s preference for a good news story. 

Analysis

Xi Jinping’s meeting with President Trump and Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC summit this week could be awkward. Jensen Huang’s affair with an alleged Chinese spy will dominate coverage. For Xi, accusations of spying will undermine diplomatic efforts to the United States and cloud any coverage of negotiations. For Trump, Huang has forced his administration’s hand in needing to appear firm against Chinese espionage and chip smuggling. Moreover, regardless of his desire to appear strong and in firm control of all aspects of US policy, Trump was damaged by the massive mid-term rebuke, and Xi and Putin will know this. 

The affair between Jensen Huang and Alice Huang sits in the center of the Venn diagram between the US-China tech race, how Washington makes decisions about regulations of the tech industry, and a stock that has driven market gains and retirement savings. It is a story that hits on multiple key interest groups, including: tech, national security, US-China relations, and executive branch-legislative relations. It is not hyperbole to say that it is one of the most consequential revelations in modern US corporate history. 

The affair is the headline. The real story is how an alleged Chinese intelligence asset coopted the most important man in the AI supply chain and whether Washington’s earlier response to allow chip exports to China was due to his outsized importance over US policymakers, including his direct line to President Trump and Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick. China has strongly denied involvement with Alice Huang, despite evidence that she served as an asset for China’s Ministry of State Security (MSS) and facilitated the transfer of around US$ 7.5 billion in Nvidia chips into China, including around US$ 5 billion through a Singapore-based company, Megaspeed. Alice Huang’s status as an MSS asset is unconfirmed, but that matters little for the headlines and subsequent reputational, regulatory, and market fallout.

In any case, for the MSS this is a failure: An alleged asset was exposed across international media; PRC espionage tactics became the leading topic of discussion across the world, and that included how the MSS uses PRC citizens to conduct its bidding. That Alice Huang has yet to be confirmed as an MSS asset is irrelevant; the headlines are out there and those who were otherwise naive to China’s tactics are now aware of their attempts to infiltrate US companies. 

The additional challenge for China is that Huang’s argument against export controls of Nvidia’s highest-performing chips will fall on increasingly deaf ears in congress. His arguments were always specious and self-serving, and now they will appear tainted by PRC intelligence. US restrictions against chip exports and other engagements with Chinese tech companies will tighten. 

More significant, however, is that the headlines of the affair suggest that China’s claims at self sufficiency are potentially overrated given that Nvidia high-performance chips are still in such high demand–at least by Chinese tech companies–over Chinese alternatives. This is despite the CCP pushing for its domestic tech champions to favor Chinese chips over Nvidia’s. The fact is that PRC actors, both commercial and governmental, had and continue to maintain an insatiable appetite for Nvidia chips and that these actors work against US commercial and national security interests.

The CCP is therefore in a bind. It will need to demonstrate that China does have the capacity to produce its own high-performance chips (or face a broad questioning of its own tech capabilities). Its mass espionage campaigns against foreign targets have also been thrust into the global spotlight, which will require assurances to China’s partners that it is not using PRC private citizens for espionage purposes, which will likely fall on deaf ears. It does not help the CCP that it has several laws on its books, including the National Intelligence Law of 2017, that require PRC citizens to render all requested assistance to China’s intelligence agencies.

In short, Huang’s affair has made it not only more difficult for China to go about business as usual, or to engage in negotiations with the United States. It has also made it more of a risk for US businesses to engage with Chinese partners or even PRC citizens without questioning whether an individual is an MSS asset. 

This will make it tough for PRC citizens working in the United States and will likely provoke suspicions that companies should guard against to protect these employees. It will also make it necessary for US companies to ensure that they have effective insider threat detection and diligence programs to protect their employees and to mitigate potential risk from their corporate partners. As discussed below, from tech policy to corporate best practices, Jensen Huang’s affair will likely cast a long shadow over US-China relations from the White House to the board room.

On the Hill: Developments in US China policy

What now for US tech policy? 

Changes were likely already coming for Silicon Valley, but Huang has accelerated a tightening of chip exports, government attention towards the US tech sector, and a tougher approach to China.   

Analysis

Huang’s relationship with an alleged Chinese spy and subsequent resignation has not only inflicted massive reputational (and economic) damage on Nvidia. It will also likely catalyze major changes in the US tech industry from intensified government scrutiny on national security grounds to a regulatory tightening on AI. 

The US government is investigating both Huangs about the nature of their relationship, what information was shared and when, and whether Alice Huang influenced Jensen Huang (and by extension, senior members of the Trump Administration) to argue for continued chip exports to China. This will be vital for US national security and how tech policy changes in the near future. 

These efforts are bipartisan. Congressional Democrats are demanding questions about Trump’s relationship with Huang and his continued engagements after being briefed on Huang’s affair. Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY) called on lawmakers to have full accounting of the relationship. Meanwhile, cabinet officials, including Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent are similarly demanding accountability from within the administration. President Trump’s friendship with Huang, and his existing knowledge of the affair even prior to inviting Huang onto Air Force One, will likely be a liability for the president as investigations proceed. 

Beyond investigations, important though they are in discerning the facts, the Huang scandal is already shaping policy. Senior members of both political parties have said that they will collectively propose measures to restrict US chip sales abroad. Huang has not necessarily changed the direction of US policy making towards China and technology, but he has provided the kindling for policy decisions to proceed at a faster pace. 

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s political future is tied to this trend given revelations that he held up the White House’s decision to crackdown on companies suspected of diverting Nvidia’s advanced chips to China. Lutnick’s logic appears to be out of concern that such moves would trigger a trade war with Beijing, but there will likely be questions about the nature of Huang’s discussions with Lutnick about the issue. In response, Senator Michael Bennet (D-CO), among others, requested updates on the US government’s investigation into Megaspeed. 

Leading the charge against Lutnick, however, appears to be Scott Bessent. In response to Bessent’s public pressure against him, Commerce announced new directives “written by and at the direction of the Department of Treasury and the National Security Council” on remote access to US-made chips. In short, policy changes (and potentially cabinet positions) are already changing thanks to Huang. US companies hoping for further wiggle room or a relaxing of regulations on economic engagements with China will likely be disappointed. 

In the context of last week’s midterm elections and the sweeping victories by Democrats, many of whom campaigned on reeling in Big Tech or opposing data centers, the likelihood was that the incoming congress would be significantly more skeptical of tech companies and their executives. Huang has made these positions far more tenable and likely to proceed. Few politicians from either party will likely want to be on record defending the same policy position as a Chinese spy. Chip exports, potentially along with other restrictions against the tech industry in the name of national security, will become increasingly prominent in policy discussions. 

One immediate outcome is that the US government has named Nvidia, among other US tech giants, as a new “national champion” through which (à la China) the US will help to steer AI companies to better compete internationally. If Nvidia or other tech companies wanted to avoid government oversight and scrutiny, this move–a direct result of Huang’s affair–demonstrates the opposite.

Business Matters

Nvidia scandal reveals fault lines in US AI sector

News of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with Megaspeed beneficial owner Alice Huang has upended both business and politics as usual. As Nvidia’s stock tumbles, the central role Nvidia plays in financing US frontier AI research is becoming clear. So is what happens if that funding dries up. Huang’s pro-China influence in Washington, moreover, is expected to give way to more hawkish voices, and this is before the new democratic congress has its say.

Analysis

While stories continue to emerge about Nvidia’s now-former CEO Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s shares plunged nearly ten percent in value in the week after the announcement of his resignation, and the company has lost more than $427B in market capitalization over two trading periods. The board’s decision to force Huang's departure has only added to the growing uncertainty over the company’s future. As Chinese media was quick to point out, Nvidia’s reliance on Huang created a “key-person risk” (关键人物风险), or the conflation of the company with one man, that has left Nvidia with no clear successor. Whether the company can come back from this scandal, and without Huang, remains an open question.

The US needs Nvidia to succeed, not only because the AI industry runs on the chips it produces, but also because Nvidia is a key financier of US AI companies, such as OpenAI and Anthropic. In circular fashion, Nvidia invests in AI companies so that AI companies can grow and create more demand for Nvidia chips. If Nvidia falters, then, it means that one of the key investors in US frontier AI research could vanish and the US could lose its advantage over its Chinese competitors. While this outcome is not a foregone conclusion, the Huang scandal has, at the very least, revealed a significant structural deficiency in the current AI sector. 

Huang’s spectacular, public downfall will also change the conversation about China in Washington. To this point in the US-China trade wars, Huang’s pro-China voice has been critical in lobbying President Trump to continue the sale of Nvidia chips to Chinese companies, despite many in the president’s cabinet hoping to punish China for flouting existing export controls. Moreover, a Commerce Department investigation into Singapore-based company Megaspeed over accusations of its delivering Nvidia chips to Chinese companies was halted after Nvidia’s intervention; this is the same company where the woman with whom Huang has admitted to having an affair, Alice Huang (Huang Le), owned the controlling stake. With such explicit evidence of Jensen Huang’s and Nvidia’s overt influence on US trade policy regarding Chinese and Chinese adjacent issues, the removal of his influence in Washington can only spell bad news for Beijing.

Beijing’s bad news gets worse. The sweeping democratic victory in the recent US election has rebalanced the new congress such that democrats will have the ability to not only launch investigations into the Trump administration’s dealings with China and Nvidia, but also to levy new tariffs and collect on existing ones (a power constitutionally given to the US Congress). While foreign policy is a domain in which the president has significant latitude, congress may attempt to prevent any significantly pro-China gestures on the president’s part. The new congress is also expected to pass additional domestic regulations on the US AI sector to regulate their behavior at home and abroad, given the president’s close relationship with Huang and the fact that Megaspeed’s Ms Huang is suspected of being a Chinese intelligence agent.

Such expanding regulations may also result in the shrinking of spaces where US companies can engage with their Chinese counterparts for legitimate business. When Hong Kong ceased to be a reliable interface between Chinese and Euro-American companies, many relocated to Singapore. Chinese-operated or affiliated companies based in Singapore, however, now have two strikes against them: first was the Manus case, when Beijing interfered and unwound the company’s sale to Meta, and now the already existing investigation into Megaspeed over allegations that the company is illegally delivering Nvidia chips to China has been compounded by the Jensen Huang/Megaspeed relationship. While the Singaporean government continues to try and placate both sides, such statements carry undertones of fear about losing US and Chinese patronage. Singapore may lose it anyway, however, as the new congress may also see this trend and attempt to regulate US companies’ operations there.

Tech Futures

Can US tech companies maintain their edge against China?

Nvidia’s likely slowdown in innovation may disrupt the US’s technological edge over China. 

Analysis

Jensen Huang will be responsible for major changes in the relationships not only between tech companies in Silicon Valley, but also between those companies and the US government. 

Nvidia, with Jensen Huang as its superstar captain, is more than just another tech company. It is arguably the keystone in the US tech industry. Nvidia is the second most-valuable company in the world for a reason: its chips underpin the necessary hardware on which AI venture labs depend, and is therefore foundational to US’s technological innovation. 

Nvidia therefore plays an outsized role not only in supporting multiple companies on which the US tech sector depends, but it is also crucial in giving the United States an edge in US-China tech competition, not to mention that it is effectively propping up the US stock market. That Jensen Huang is synonymous with Nvidia is both an asset and an enormous risk, as demonstrated by the company’s slumping stock value (a loss of nearly US$2 trillion in value) in the wake of the scandal.

The financing part is key. Nvidia is, at least according to The Economist, Silicon Valley’s “central bank” whereby Nvidia invests in tech companies, which then purchase its chips, and so on in a series of interconnected financing and equity deals. In short, if Nvidia fails, it will likely burst the AI bubble and likely precipitate the partial collapse of the US tech sector, and with it the market and the country’s current leadership in the US-China tech race. 

From a US government perspective, this makes Nvidia an extremely vulnerable point in the tech sector and the United States’ economic security. It also made Jensen Huang one of the most valuable targets for Chinese corporate espionage efforts. Huang highlights a key vulnerability for many tech companies: the visibility of their former CEO as the embodiment of the company with little in the way of a successor apparent or other executives able to move into a similar position as the company’s leader. Nvidia’s future as the lynchpin of the US tech industry appears not only in doubt, but by extension so potentially does the ability for AI frontier labs to maintain their technological edge over PRC-based competitors. 

Nvidia also highlights American companies’ dependence on China. As some of Nvidia’s largest customers, PRC-based companies, and by extension Beijing, wielded leverage over the company’s business decisions, which in turn challenged US national security. As mentioned above (see above in On the Hill), the US government is increasingly attentive to how the US commercial sector now plays a central role in national security. That will change the calculation for US companies, particularly in the tech sector, regarding how their customers, suppliers, and other corporate engagements shape and are shaped by changing geopolitical, security, and regulatory concerns, not in the least because the US government sees China in far more adversarial terms than do many US companies. 

But the broader context of Huang’s case should similarly alert US companies to the need to defend against similar targeting against their employees, IP, or other systems. At the very least, completely depending on Nvidia’s hardware, funding, or other interactions should be considered a liability. The key challenge will be how to replace these when the company is so dominant. The US government and the private sector will need to reconsider their risk-reward calculation of short-term economic benefits of dependence on Nvidia and China as a supplier and customer. This will be difficult but necessary to prevent future negative influence and leverage that stem from reliance on corporate or geopolitical pinch points. 

That will likely require a much broader accounting and reconfiguring of the US tech sector. Tech companies will find that in the long term, this recalculation of risk will provide more profits as they earn more, for longer periods, from their intellectual property. In the short-term, however, this will be painful as it means forgoing larger profits. This is because China’s goal is to supplant US companies in favor of their own. Companies will need to understand that longer term survival is worth prioritizing over shorter term gains.

Espionage Alert

Huang is the headline; foreign commercial espionage is far, far more widespread

Huang is the latest case, but foreign commercial espionage, especially by China, is endemic. Companies need to defend against a massive, decades-long effort that  targets employees from CEOs, interns, and everyone in between. 

Analysis

The Huang scandal is perhaps the most consequential commercial espionage scandal of recent times. Yet despite the headlines, Huang’s case is but the latest, albeit most high-profile, example of what is a common and often undetected and unreported form of commercial  intelligence extraction. Huang was perhaps the biggest target, but his case broke the news because of his fame and importance to the world economy. Thousands of other cases targeting far more junior individuals nevertheless carry the same risks, particularly when those targeted have access to sensitive company information.  

Honeytrap infiltration is a common espionage technique. Former US Representative Eric Swalwell was also caught in a scandal with an alleged Chinese spy. The challenge for US businesses is that these kinds of infiltration techniques are no longer reserved for politicians or intelligence operatives, but now increasingly target Western business leaders, managers, and even junior employees. 

As discussed in our previous Red Report, Nvidia’s example also demonstrates how our system lacks the legal framework, political will, and the resources to shield companies from foreign espionage. Having an insider threat team is no longer a luxury reserved for larger companies or those in certain sectors like defense or tech. Instead, funding insider threat teams will be a necessary investment to continuing business in the face of the increasingly explicit and multi-vector targeting of US intellectual property across multiple sectors. This includes protecting employees against those who try to leverage personal relationships with corporate insiders for corporate gain. 

As Nvidia is learning in real time, the cost of failing to monitor and mitigate such threats risks financial, compliance, and reputational fallout that will tarnish both the company and Huang’s reputation for the foreseeable future. Mitigation depends on a company’s circumstances, but corporate defense should be forward looking and continuous and not require evidence of wrongdoing to be implemented. In Alice Huang’s case, the warning signs were there even if there was no single smoking gun: a thin public profile, rapid partner approval, large-scale purchases, and corporate ties to PRC entities should all have triggered enhanced diligence on Megaspeed. 

This diligence should have included employee exposure diligence, foreign contact reporting, end-user verification, and executive security briefings that would have occurred had these systems been part of Nvidia’s corporate protocol and culture. The goal is not to punish or create a culture of suspicion but to protect those employees who may not even be aware that they are being targeted.  

Huang may be the most prominent individual to fall for a honeytrap, but he is one of many. He most certainly will not be the last. Every US company needs to plan and prepare for how a similar event could ripple throughout their business and sector.

Book Recs

What we’re reading to better understand China

❝

If you would like additional information and analysis tailored specifically for your specific business or institution, please contact us at [email protected].

Reply

Avatar

or to participate